What Year Harleys to Avoid: A Comprehensive Guide for Enthusiasts

Harley-Davidson is an iconic brand with a legacy that spans over a century. Owning a Harley is not just about having a motorcycle; it’s about being part of a community, a culture, and a tradition. However, not all Harleys are created equal. Over the years, certain models have garnered reputations that may make you think twice before buying. In this article, we’ll dive deep into the specific years of Harley-Davidson motorcycles that enthusiasts often suggest avoiding, along with the reasons why. Whether you’re a seasoned rider or new to the Harley family, this guide will help you make an informed decision.

The Infamous AMF Era (1969-1981)

When discussing the history of Harley-Davidson, it’s impossible not to mention the AMF years. American Machine and Foundry (AMF) took over Harley-Davidson in 1969, a period that is often criticized for declining quality. During this time, Harley struggled with production quality and reliability, leading to a tarnished reputation.

Why Should You Avoid Harleys from This Era?

1. Quality Control Issues: The AMF years are notorious for quality control problems. Due to cost-cutting measures, many bikes left the factory with issues that should have been caught during production. Riders often reported oil leaks, electrical problems, and poor assembly.
2. Increased Maintenance: If you’re looking for a Harley that offers a smooth riding experience with minimal fuss, the AMF-era bikes might not be for you. These models often require more maintenance and frequent repairs, which can be both time-consuming and expensive.
3. Resale Value: Harleys from this era tend to have lower resale value compared to other years. Collectors and enthusiasts generally prefer models from before or after AMF’s ownership due to their superior build quality.

The 2003 Anniversary Models

The 2003 models were meant to celebrate Harley-Davidson’s 100th anniversary, but they ended up being a mixed bag. While some owners have had no issues, others have reported a range of problems that make these models less desirable.

Common Issues with 2003 Models

1. Paint Problems: Many owners have complained about the paint quality on the 2003 anniversary models. The special anniversary paint job, which should have been a selling point, often peeled or faded prematurely.
2. Cam Chain Tensioner Failure: This is a significant mechanical issue that has affected several models from this year. The cam chain tensioner failure can lead to catastrophic engine damage if not addressed in time, requiring expensive repairs or even engine replacement.
3. Electrical Problems: Another common complaint among 2003 Harley owners is electrical issues. From faulty wiring to dead batteries, these problems can cause significant headaches.

The 2014 Harley-Davidson Street 500 and 750

When Harley-Davidson introduced the Street 500 and 750 models in 2014, they aimed to appeal to new riders and urban commuters. However, these models quickly became known for several drawbacks that could make you think twice before buying.

Why the 2014 Street Models Might Not Be for You

1. Build Quality Concerns: The Street 500 and 750 were among Harley’s first models to be produced overseas, and many riders have pointed out that the build quality does not live up to Harley’s standards. Common complaints include poor welds, low-quality materials, and parts that wear out quickly.
2. Braking Issues: One of the most critical safety concerns reported with these models is inadequate braking performance. Riders have noted that the brakes feel weak, making it difficult to stop quickly in emergencies.
3. Recalls and Warranty Repairs: The 2014 Street models have been subject to several recalls, including issues with fuel tanks and brake calipers. While Harley has addressed these issues under warranty, the frequency of recalls has led many to question the reliability of these bikes.

The 2007 Twin Cam Models

The Twin Cam engine, introduced in 1999, is generally well-regarded. However, the 2007 models, which featured an updated version of this engine, have been the subject of controversy due to mechanical issues that have caused significant frustration for some owners.

What Went Wrong with the 2007 Twin Cam Models?

1. Cam Chain Tensioner Problems: Similar to the 2003 models, the 2007 Twin Cam models also suffered from cam chain tensioner issues. This problem can lead to engine failure if not addressed promptly, resulting in costly repairs.
2. Transmission Issues: Some 2007 models have been reported to experience transmission problems, including difficulty shifting gears and unusual noises. These issues can detract from the riding experience and may require expensive fixes.
3. Oil Pump Failures: Another issue that has plagued the 2007 Twin Cam models is oil pump failure. An oil pump failure can cause engine damage if not detected early, leading to significant repair costs.

The 2018 Harley-Davidson Softail

The 2018 Softail models were part of a significant redesign that combined the Dyna and Softail lineups into a single platform. While this redesign brought many improvements, it also introduced some issues that make these models less appealing to some riders.

Potential Drawbacks of the 2018 Softail Models

1. Suspension Complaints: The new suspension system introduced in the 2018 Softail models has received mixed reviews. Some riders find it too stiff, leading to a less comfortable ride, especially on longer trips.
2. Fit and Finish Issues: Some owners have reported issues with the fit and finish of the 2018 Softail models. These complaints include misaligned parts, loose bolts, and other minor but annoying defects that detract from the overall experience.
3. Ergonomics: While ergonomics are often a matter of personal preference, some riders have found the new design less comfortable, particularly for taller riders. The riding position may not suit everyone, leading to discomfort on longer rides.

The Importance of Regular Maintenance

While certain years and models of Harley-Davidson motorcycles have garnered negative reputations, it’s important to remember that regular maintenance can go a long way in preventing issues. Even if you own a model from one of the years mentioned above, diligent upkeep can help you avoid many common problems.

Tips for Maintaining Your Harley

1. Regular Oil Changes: Keeping your engine oil fresh and clean is crucial for the longevity of your Harley. Make sure to follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for oil change intervals.
2. Check and Replace Worn Parts: Pay attention to parts that are prone to wear and tear, such as tires, brake pads, and chains. Replacing these parts before they fail can prevent more serious issues down the road.
3. Keep Up with Recalls: If your model has been subject to a recall, make sure to address it promptly. Ignoring recalls can lead to dangerous situations and costly repairs.

Conclusion: Making an Informed Decision

When it comes to buying a Harley-Davidson, doing your research is key. While the brand has produced many reliable and beloved motorcycles over the years, certain models and years have gained reputations that make them worth avoiding. The AMF-era bikes, the 2003 anniversary models, the 2014 Street series, the 2007 Twin Cam models, and the 2018 Softails all have their share of issues that potential buyers should be aware of.

That said, every bike has its pros and cons, and what might be a deal-breaker for one rider could be a minor inconvenience for another. If you find a model from one of these years that you love, just be prepared for the potential challenges and make sure to keep up with regular maintenance.

Ultimately, the best Harley for you is the one that fits your riding style, meets your expectations, and brings you joy every time you hit the road. Happy riding!